Federal Judge Michael Ponsor has weighed in on the recent upside-down American flag incident at Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito’s home, calling it unethical in an op-ed for The New York Times on Friday. Ponsor stated that regardless of its legality, displaying the flag in such a manner and at that time should not have occurred, as it was improper and lacking in judgment.
An upside-down American flag, which is used by supporters of former President Donald Trump who believe that President Joe Biden did not win the 2020 election, was spotted flying at Alito’s home in the weeks following the January 6 riot. The New York Times first reported this incident.
Ponsor, a senior judge on the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, criticized the Supreme Court for taking sides in this manner, which he argues erodes public trust in courts and judges. He further emphasizes that Alito’s wife was responsible for hanging the flag, stating that it is not unreasonable to expect a spouse to avoid actions that may embarrass their partner or complicate their professional life.
Another symbol associated with Trump supporters, an “Appeal to Heaven” flag, was seen flying at a beach home owned by Alito in New Jersey, as reported by the Times days later. The flag dates back to the Revolutionary War and is also connected to the desire for a Christian government. Ponsor maintains that basic ethical behavior should not rely on laws or regulations but should be an integral part of a judge’s character.
In his op-ed, Ponsor reiterates the importance of maintaining public trust in the judiciary and calls for judges to adhere to higher ethical standards. He is not alone in criticizing the Supreme Court; other sitting federal judges have also voiced their concerns about the court’s ethics standards and integrity.
As a result of the flag controversy, Justice Alito faces calls from members of the media and Democratic lawmakers to recuse himself from Trump-related cases. Ponsor’s op-ed serves as a reminder that upholding public trust in the judiciary is paramount, and judges must exhibit strong ethical behavior in their personal and professional lives.
