Cary Williams, a former competitive female boxer and Olympic level boxing coach, has expressed her concerns about the future of women’s boxing following a controversial decision by one of the sport’s governing bodies. The decision allows biological males who have transitioned to female to compete against women in the ring. Williams warns that this move will not only lead to women getting injured but also take away opportunities from female boxers. She believes that allowing men to fight against women in a sport that involves physical contact is a dangerous decision.
Earlier this year, USA Boxing announced that a fighter who has transitioned from male to female can compete in the female category under certain conditions, including hormone levels and completion of gender surgery. Williams argues that this decision will result in severe harm to girls and women in the ring. Drawing from her own experience of sparring with a 16-year-old male as a 30-year-old fighter, she highlights the physical and biological differences between males and females. Williams emphasizes that she never imagined discussing men being allowed to fight against women and believes that this decision goes against common sense.
In addition to her concerns, Williams also mentions that many individuals fear speaking out against transgender competition in sports due to the potential backlash, describing it as a “cancel culture.” She believes that it is essential to base decisions on reality and science rather than ideology. Williams acknowledges that individuals have the right to transition but argues that there are consequences to such decisions, including being unable to compete as a woman in sports. She emphasizes that women have fought hard for their place in sports and suggests that transgender athletes should create their own space over time, rather than immediately competing against women.
USA Boxing responded to the criticism by pointing to its transgender policy, which requires transgender athletes to have completed full surgical reassignment, multiple years of hormone therapy, and hormone testing to prove their levels are within acceptable ranges. However, Williams and others continue to raise concerns about the negative impact of including biological males in women’s sports.
The controversy surrounding the inclusion of transgender athletes in women’s sports extends beyond boxing and has raised questions about fairness and the integrity of competition. Critics argue that allowing biological males to compete against females can result in unfair advantages due to inherent physical differences. On the other hand, proponents argue for inclusivity and equal opportunities for transgender athletes.
As the debate continues, the future of women’s sports remains uncertain. Williams warns that if biological men continue to be allowed in women’s sports, it could jeopardize the progress women have made in establishing their right to compete. The issue involves various layers, and finding a balance that respects both inclusivity and fair competition is a challenge that sports organizations and policymakers must address.
