In the wake of the October 7 attacks by Hamas, Israel’s left-wing is grappling with an identity crisis as the country experiences a surge in nationalism. The events of that day, which saw Hamas break out of the Gaza Strip and carry out surprise attacks in southern Israel, have deeply affected Israeli society. Many individuals who previously identified as left-wing have found their views shifting to the right as they reflect on where they stand in this emotionally charged period.
Danielle, a 22-year-old who describes herself as a leftie, shares how the events of October 7 have challenged her political views. Prior to the attacks, there was a willingness to understand the perspective of people in Gaza who supported Hamas, but now that has changed. “I am paying taxes for Gaza’s electricity and water, but Hamas is just taking that money and investing it in rockets instead of education,” Danielle says.
The wave of nationalism sweeping through Israel is evident in the proliferation of Israeli flags hanging from street lamps and the government’s constant stream of jingoistic rhetoric. This atmosphere has led to a shift in the political landscape, with individuals on the left wrestling with an internal conflict as traditional political divisions temporarily fade away.
Some left-wing protesters in Tel Aviv have adopted a more militant approach, while others have become more patriotic in response to the attacks. Talia Keinan, an artist, expresses concern about the thin line between self-defense and revenge, cautioning against further escalating violence. Gai Sherf, a musician, emphasizes the need to break the cycle of violence and act differently in response to the attacks.
The events of October 7 have left a lasting impact on the kibbutz community, which largely votes for left-wing parties. Aldema, a photographer, points out that the communities targeted by Hamas were predominantly pro-Palestinian. While still desiring peace, he believes the left needs to be more realistic about the necessity of a military response.
There is ongoing confusion among leftists regarding their stance on occupation and the very existence of the state of Israel. Some feel disappointed by the international left, which they perceive as hypocritical for not condemning Hamas’s attacks. However, opposition to occupation is expected to revitalize in the long run.
Meanwhile, the government’s deliberate efforts to radicalize the Israeli public and incite them against Palestinians contribute to the growing divide. Roee Aloni, director of public outreach at B’tselem, an Israeli human rights group, warns that the current heated political climate makes it difficult to draw conclusions about where Israeli progressives will ultimately stand.
Amidst the political wrangling, many individuals recognize the importance of putting aside differences to support the families of the kidnapped Israelis. Solidarity with the captives’ families takes precedence over political grievances during this tumultuous time.
As Israel navigates its way through this crisis, it remains to be seen how the events of October 7 will permanently shape left-wing politics in the country. The emotional toll of the attacks has undoubtedly led to shifts in political views, but the long-term ramifications are still uncertain.
